Cure for grapevine trunk diseases?

There has been a breakthrough in the search to find a remedy for Eutypa dieback and Esca – two of the most devastating vineyard diseases…


Report co-authors Elsa Petit (left) and Dana Sebestyen (right) conducting research at the UMass Amherst Cold Spring Vineyard. Photos courtesy of Barry Goodell

Cure for grapevine trunk diseases?
  • Chris Boiling
  • 2022-08-23
‘This research represents a breakthrough in ways that we understand this devastating disease of vineyards and how to control that devastation’
Researchers in the United States, France, Italy and Chile, working together, have unlocked the mystery of grapevine trunk diseases (GTD). They have discovered the ‘missing link’ – a previously unknown mechanism that is deployed by a group of pathogenic fungi working in concert and which are responsible for the death of huge numbers vines.
While researchers have long known that a host of pathogenic fungi combine to gang up on grapevines, the mechanics of how these GTD-causing fungi work has remained a mystery.
However, a fairly easy, cost-effective solution may be on the horizon now that an international cohort of researchers, led by the University of Massachusetts Amherst, has identified the mechanism that has devastated vineyards around the world.
GTDs such as Eutypa dieback, Esca, and Botryosphaeria dieback have been known to kill up to 30% of the vines in a single vineyard each year, and typically attack older, well-established vines. In California alone, annual GTD-related losses amount to 14% of the total value of the wine grapes produced.
Leading viticulturist Dr Richard Smart described grapevine trunk diseases to Canopy as “a substantial threat to world viticulture” and possibly worse than phylloxera.
He said in a 2019 article: “There is clear evidence that the incidence of trunk disease is increasing in many vineyard regions of the world. Some trunk disease experts predict that the disease is probably present in every one of the world’s vineyards. Certainly, since I have learned to recognise the symptoms in 2011, I have not been in a vineyard anywhere since where I have failed to find symptoms, which includes visits to vineyard regions in over 20 countries including the tropics.”

GTD Eutypa canker
Here is an example of the effect: a cross-section of grapevine trunk with necrosis and wood degradation typical of Eutypa dieback.

‘The missing ingredient’

GTD-causing fungi typically enter the vine’s system through pruning wounds and, once established, develop a rotting canker that gradually expands, dissolving the woody part of the vine from the inside out and killing the plant. It’s no easy feat to dissolve the tough cellulose and lignin framework that make up woody plants, but a consortium of fungi figured out how to do it, perplexing scientists.
“The missing ingredient,” says Barry Goodell, professor of microbiology at UMass Amherst, and the paper’s senior author, “is an understanding of what very small compounds produced by the fungi are actually doing to the grapevines.”
In particular, Goodell and his UMass Amherst colleagues and students, along with collaborating scientists from the University of Florence in Italy, the Université de Lorraine and the Université de Haute-Alsace, both in France, and the University of Concepción in Chile, as well as vineyard owners in both France and Italy, have discovered that some of the GTD-causing fungi produce different types of small compounds that are released into the wood of the vine. One of those compounds is responsible for reducing iron. Normally, we encounter iron as the chemical compound Fe3+. Reducing iron from Fe3+ to Fe2+ sets the stage for some nasty grapevine problems.

Reducing iron from Fe3+ to Fe2+ sets the stage for some nasty grapevine problems.
“But that’s not the whole story,” Goodell says. “We also discovered that there’s another set of small compounds that are produced by other fungi in the consortia, and these compounds are really good at producing hydrogen peroxide. When hydrogen peroxide meets reduced iron – BOOM! – the reaction releases a host of oxygen radicals that damage the woody tissue causing an almost cancer-like disease.”
In short, different fungi, each producing one of the two types of small compounds needed for an extracellular bomb, figured out how to get together, mix their respective chemicals, and use them to blow apart the cellulose walls of the grapevine’s cells. Once the cell walls are breached, the fungi can feast on the sugar-rich fluid that once was the cellular structure supporting the vine’s own growth.

GTD Fig 4
This image shows the proposed mechanism for the in-situ generation of Fe2+ and H2O2, and degradation of lignin and cell wall macromolecules by GTD fungi. The low molecular weight (LMW) metabolites and H2O2 diffuse into the cell wall, where the LMW metabolites sequester Fe3+ from the cell wall environment and reduce Fe3+ to Fe2+. Through a type of Chelator-mediated Fenton (CMF) reaction, Fe2+ and H2O2 react and generate hydroxyl radicals.

‘When hydrogen peroxide meets reduced iron – BOOM! – the reaction releases a host of oxygen radicals that damage the woody tissue causing an almost cancer-like disease’
GTD - Barry Vineyard
Luckily, there’s a potential fix, which is so common consumers probably eat it every morning with cereal: antioxidants and low-toxicity chelators. Often added to food products to preserve freshness, they also interrupt the production of reduced iron and hydrogen peroxide. They also scavenge the oxygen radicals the fungi produce. “In addition,” Goodell (above) points out, “there are some select bacteria and fungi that produce these antioxidant and chelating compounds. Our research shows that we may be able to manage and stop GTDs through ‘bio-control’ treatments by increasing the natural presence of these antagonistic organisms on the vines.”
He adds: “Of course, there’s still work to be done. Vineyard pathologists need to test our research in the field, and other microbiologists will want to verify our work. But we already have colleagues as part of our larger team that are doing this, and we’re confident that this research represents a breakthrough in ways that we understand this devastating disease of vineyards and how to control that devastation."

The research was published in the journals Fungal Biology and Frontiers in Plant Science, and was supported by the USDA-NIFA Hatch Multistate Program and the Microbiology Department at UMass, the French/European VitEST project and Laboratoire Vigne Biotechnologies et Environnement at University Haute-Alsace, and DAGRI at the University of Florence, Italy.

Sign up to Canopy’s mailing list

Get free insights into the global wine business.

We never share your contact details with 3rd parties.

Sign Up Now
  • Sponsors of the Supermarket of the Year Award
  • Sponsors of the Champion Wine Awards
  • Sponsors of the Great Value Sake Award
  • Sponsors of Buying Team of the Year
  • Sponsors of the Large Agent of the Year
  • Sponsors of the Large Independent of the Year Award
  • Sponsors of Wine Educator of the Year
  • Sponsors of IWC Online Retailer of the Year
  • Sponsors of IWC Sake Brewer of the Year
  • Sponsors of IWC Champion Sake of the Year
  • Sponsors of the Rosé Specialist Merchant of the Year Award
  • Supporter 3
  • Supporter 4